Why Lawyers + Law Firm Branding = Identity Crisis (And the Solution)
- Julie Fisher
- Jul 3
- 7 min read
Why Most Lawyers Get Branding Wrong And Why You Need an Expert
If you’re a lawyer, you’ve probably heard the term “branding” more times than you can count. You might even believe you know what it means by now. After all, you have a logo, a website, and some marketing materials in play and you’re getting calls and emails from potential clients.
But here’s the uncomfortable truth: most law firms are missing the mark on branding, and it’s costing them credibility, trust, and new business. The type of desired leads they want contacting their firm because they know those are the cases they want to handle.
As someone who’s spent years leading law firm marketing initiatives, I saw those same mistakes over and over firsthand. Best laid intentions attempting to do marketing, and, seeing that even some agencies got it wrong!
Branding is not a synonym for marketing. It’s not merely a logo. It’s not your tagline. And it’s definitely not a collection of disconnected social media posts or a shiny new website.
Let’s set the record straight and show you what real branding looks like for law firms and why it’s the foundation of your law firm’s long-term authority and growth.
What Branding Actually Means
Branding is your law firm’s reputation. It’s how people perceive you based on every interaction, every impression, and every story they hear about your practice. It’s not just what you say about yourself; it’s what your clients, peers, and the market believe about you.
Emotional Connection: Your brand is defined by the emotions it stirs and the meaningful relationships it builds. When your clients feel understood and valued, you create loyalty that goes far beyond a single case.
Example: If your firm is known for fast, friendly service in personal injury cases, that’s part of your brand. It’s the stories clients tell after working with you, the reviews they leave, and the feeling they get from your team.
Memorable Experiences: It’s not solely about your products or services, but the lasting impressions and feelings you leave with every interaction. Every client touchpoint, from intake to case resolution, shapes how your brand is remembered.
Why it matters: A strong brand helps you stand out and attract the right clients. Without it, you’re just another name in a crowded market.
Visual Branding: More Than a Pretty Logo
Visual branding is just one piece of the puzzle. It’s your logo, colors, website design, and even your office decor. But here’s the catch: most law firms default to the same tired visuals of the scales of justice, gavels, and navy blue everything. That’s not branding; that’s blending in.
Distinct Identity: A brand is the unique combination of traits that distinguishes you from competitors and makes you stand out. Your visuals should reflect your firm’s personality and values, not just industry clichés.
Example: A memorable color scheme and a modern logo (not just law books or columns) set your firm apart. When clients see your materials, they should instantly recognize who you are and what you stand for.
Why it matters: Consistent, distinctive visuals make your firm look professional and memorable, not generic.
Positioning: The Most Overlooked (and Most Important) Branding Task
Positioning is how your firm is perceived compared to your competitors. It’s the answer to “Why should I hire you instead of the firm down the street?” This is where most law firms fall flat. Be a generalist and you will get all things general…not the specific specialty that creates your unique value.
Vision: Your brand is driven by the future you aim to create. Positioning your firm with a clear vision attracts clients who share your values and goals.
Example: If you’re a real estate law firm, don’t just say, “We handle all real estate matters.” Instead, position yourself as “The only firm specializing in commercial lease disputes for small business owners.” Now you’re not just another option; you’re the option for a specific client.
Key insight: Positioning is always comparative. It’s about knowing your competitors and clearly defining how you are different or better. If your competitors are generalists, become the go-to specialist. If they compete on price, you might focus on superior service or outcomes. And, you can have more than one practice (our services) page that shows your legal expertise in other fields of law. Remember, we are looking to establish who is the primary client your law firm desires to have and build their trust in your brand.
Messaging: Speak to Clients, Not Just Other Lawyers
Messaging is the language and tone you use to communicate your value. Legal jargon may impress your peers, but it confuses and alienates clients. Effective messaging is about clarity, empathy, and relevance. Who is your audience and how should you be connecting with them?
Communication: How you share your message shapes your brand. It’s not just the words you use, but the way you express them that matters—clear, empathetic communication builds trust and credibility.
Example: Instead of “We provide comprehensive legal services in real estate law,” try, “We help small business owners resolve commercial lease disputes quickly and affordably.”
Why it matters: Clear, client-focused messaging builds trust and helps clients feel understood; critical for referrals and retention. When you speak to their need, they feel heard.
Branding Is Never “Set It and Forget It”
Branding is not a one-time project. It demands ongoing attention, regular updates, and adjustments based on feedback and market changes. One just doesn’t simply build a website and leave it there. Google has made it clear; they love fresh content and they will check for it regularly. Then, there are the new trends that require a touch-up to stay relevant.
Reputation: A brand is what others say about you when you’re not present. Your reputation is built overtime through consistent actions and results.
Example: Refreshing your website, updating testimonials, or tweaking your tagline as your firm evolves keeps your brand relevant.
Why it matters: If you ignore your brand, it becomes stale and so does your reputation. An “older” style website can lead potential new clients to believe you are outdated and not on top of your trade. It has to do with building credibility and, believe me, your larger law firms are doing it.
How Law Firms Lose Credibility
Many lawyers believe that a slick website or a new brochure equals branding. But when your materials, website, and social posts don’t align with your true strengths and values, clients sense the disconnect. The same applies when proper color guidelines and imagery are not implemented, it creates confusion; even the slightest error can create an emotional disconnect. And, you don’t want that; it erodes trust and can impact your firm’s appeal.
Core Values:These are the guiding principles you uphold, even when no one is watching. If your branding doesn’t reflect your real values, clients will sense the disconnect and lose trust.
What’s missing?
· Message and visual consistency across all touchpoints
· A clear, comparative position in the market
· Messaging that resonates with real clients, not just other lawyers
Brand Authority: The Ultimate Goal
Brand authority is earned by consistently delivering on your promises, demonstrating expertise, and communicating your unique value at every opportunity. This means:
Trust and Promises:A brand embodies the commitments you make and consistently honor. Earning trust is about delivering on your promises every time, not just once.
Advanced Branding Strategies:
· Thought leadership through educational content (blogs, webinars, CLEs)
· Elevating lawyer profiles on their bio page, legal directories, LinkedIn and in the media
· Proactively managing your online reputation and client reviews
· Staying consistent with established brand guidelines on all visuals and marketing collateral
· Forge alliances with related professionals to create a unique value proposition
· Combine digital, in-person, and partnership channels for maximum reach and brand reinforcement
· Coaching your law firm staff to know your firm’s brand guidelines so everyone speaks the right message and your marketing handles the collateral needs. No rogue players!
Workplace Culture: Your brand is reflected in the culture you nurture within your organization. A positive, empowered team is essential for delivering on your brand promise at every client touchpoint.
The Bottom Line
Branding is not about what you put on your business card or website. It’s about the reputation you build, the trust you earn, and the authority you demonstrate in your field. Most law firms get it wrong because they treat branding as a box to check, not a strategic foundation.
“Branding is not what you say about yourself. It’s what your clients and the market believe about you. If you want your law firm to be known, respected, and chosen, you need more than marketing materials. You need a real, strategic brand.”
– Julie Fisher, CEO of Fisher Marketing Services LLC
Your law firm needs real brand development and authority. That’s where Fisher Marketing Services comes in. As a legal marketing executive, I break down what branding actually means for law firms, why it matters, and how brand authority is built (and lost) in the legal world. I help translate branding theory into actionable, measurable strategies that build trust, authority, and result for your law firm.
If you’re ready to move beyond the basics and build a law firm brand that commands attention and trust, let’s talk. Branding isn’t just what you look like; it’s who you are in the eyes of your clients and your market. And it’s time to get it right.
Interested in learning how these strategies can work for your firm? Contact Fisher Marketing Services for a tailored consultation and discover how to take your law firm’s brand to a whole new level and gain a competitive advantage.
Comments